Real Estate vs. Stocks Calculator

Aptoria

Features

Product

Resources

Company

Tools

Pricing

See the demo

Free calculator

Real estate vs. stocks calculator

Project the same starting capital forward at two rates you choose — one for a rental, one for a stock index fund — and compare. It’s an illustration of your assumptions, not investment advice.

Get early access

Watch it work

An illustration of your inputs — not investment advice.

The short answer

Last updated: July 2026

This tool compares real estate and stocks by projecting the same starting capital forward at two annual returns you enter — one for a rental, one for a stock index fund — compounded over a horizon you choose. It’s strictly an illustration of your own assumptions, not historical data, a prediction, or investment advice about which to pick.

Real estate vs. stocks calculator

The same capital, two assumed rates.

Enter a starting amount and the annual return you'd assume for each path — a rental and a stock index fund — and see them compound side by side. An illustration of your inputs, not advice.

Starting capital

For a rental this is usually the down payment you'd invest.

Assumed real-estate return / yr

15%

Assumed stock return / yr

15%

Years

20 yrs

1 yr

40 yrs

Input-driven result

Your inputs

Formula

Result below

Real estate in 20 yrs

$279,657

$60,000 compounded at 8% a year.

Stocks in 20 yrs

$232,181

$60,000 compounded at 7% a year.

Real estate ends ahead by

$47,476

The gap between the two paths at the rates you entered.

Estimate based on your inputs. Not a promise of results.

Illustration only — not investment advice, and Aptoria is not an investment advisor. It simply compounds the rates you chose; it ignores leverage, rental cash flow, dividends, fees, and taxes, and makes no claim about which path is better. Projected returns are not guaranteed.

Get early access

Watch it work

How it works

How this tool works.

A down payment is capital, and capital has options. The same money could go into a rental property or into a broad stock index fund — and the long-run difference comes down to the annual return each earns and how many years it compounds. Seeing both grow side by side makes the trade-off concrete.

This calculator takes one starting amount and projects it forward at two annual rates you enter — one you’d expect from real estate, one from stocks — over a horizon you set. It is strictly an illustration of the rates you choose. It is explicitly not investment advice, and it makes no claim about which is better or what any real return will be.

Enter your starting capital — for a rental, this is typically the down payment you’d put in.

Set an assumed annual return for the real-estate path and a separate assumed annual return for the stock path — these are your assumptions, not our recommendations.

Choose how many years to project; the tool compounds each amount annually at its own rate.

Compare the two projected values and the gap between them. It’s a pure compounding illustration of the rates you entered — not a prediction, and not advice to pick either one.

Make the result useful

Compare assumptions before comparing outcomes

Real estate and stocks can differ in leverage, liquidity, taxes, concentration, management effort, and transaction costs. A return comparison is only as useful as the inputs you make comparable.

Use after-cost assumptions and state the time horizon. A modeled stock return does not include property work; a modeled property return should not omit expenses or financing.

Worked example

Comparing $50,000 invested for ten years requires a return assumption for each asset and a clear treatment of property debt and operating cash flow.

Rental property ROI guide →

Cap rate vs cash-on-cash →

Rental property bookkeeping →

Which asset is better?

The calculator does not make an investment recommendation.

Answers

Questions, answered plainly.

Is this investment advice?

No. Aptoria is not an investment advisor, and this tool gives no recommendation. It only compounds the two returns you enter over the years you choose, so you can see how the assumptions play out. Which path fits you is a decision for you and a qualified advisor.

Why doesn’t it use real historical returns?

Because past returns don’t predict future ones, and baking in a “market average” would dress up an assumption as a fact. You enter both rates, so the result is transparently an illustration of your own inputs — try conservative and optimistic figures to see the range.

Does it account for leverage, rental cash flow, or taxes?

No — it’s a simple side-by-side compounding of one lump sum at two rates. Real estate involves leverage, ongoing cash flow, maintenance, and different tax treatment; stocks have their own tax and dividend profile. This tool deliberately strips all of that out to isolate the rate comparison.

Which one should I choose?

The calculator won’t say, and neither will we — that depends on your goals, risk tolerance, taxes, and how hands-on you want to be. It’s a thinking aid for the rates you supply, not a signal to buy either asset.

Keep exploring

More tools for analyze a deal.

Rental property ROI calculator

Estimate cap rate, cash flow, and cash-on-cash from your numbers.

Open tool →

Cap rate calculator

Estimate cap rate and NOI from price, income, and expenses.

Open tool →

Gross rent multiplier (GRM) calculator

Estimate the GRM — price relative to a year of gross rent.

Open tool →

This calculator compounds the rates you enter and is for illustration only. It is not investment advice, and Aptoria is not an investment advisor. Projected returns are not guaranteed; consult a qualified financial advisor for your situation.

Built by a landlord who's done every one of these jobs by hand.

Aptoria was built by an owner-operator managing a Brooklyn portfolio — the 11pm calls, the awkward rent texts, the April receipt-pile — not by a software team guessing at the problem.

Stop sizing the problem. Let the agent run it.

Free for your first unit. The calculator gives you the number; Aptoria does the work — and you approve what matters.

Start free

Self-management software

Aptoria

The modern operating system for rental portfolios. Built for landlords, by people who manage units.

Product